Water Heater Repair & Replacement Services in Wisconsin & Minnesota
We’ve assisted homeowners for over 65 years and will proudly service your home as well.
Free Reverse Osmosis System
with Whole Home Water Care System
Cannot be combined with any other offers. Must present coupon at time of service. Not valid on previously completed work.
Highly Rated
Satisfaction Guaranteed
Family Owned
Friendly Technicians
Determining when to repair or replace your water heater can be tough. Generally speaking, water heaters have an average lifespan of about 10 years. As your water heater approaches or passes that threshold, you should weigh the cost to repair the water heater against the cost to replace it.If faced with a $500 repair compared to a thousand dollar replacement cost on a water heater over 6 years old, you may give serious thought to replacing the water heater. If the water heater tank is leaking, you will have no choice but to replace it since the tank is not repairable.
The type of water heater that is best for your home will depend on several things. For instance, you will need a product that is big enough to handle all of your home hot water needs.You don’t want to wind up with a water heater that is too small so that you are constantly running out of hot water. But, of course, the bigger the water heater is, the more expensive it will be to purchase and run, so you don’t want to get one that is bigger than necessary either. You also need to decide what type of fuel you would like your water heater to run on.
The initial cost to install or replace an electric water heater is a little less than a gas water heater. Gas water heaters require venting for the combustion gases as well as gas piped to the water heater. Whereas an electric water heater only requires a single wire from the home’s circuit breaker panel to power the unit.Generally speaking, gas water heaters produce a larger amount of hot water more quickly than electric water heaters. For this reason, many homes with gas water heaters have 40-gallon tanks versus a 50-gallon tank which is average for electric units. When it comes to the cost of operation, the gas water heater wins hands down.
Another significant element to consider when performing a water heater replacement is whether you want a system with a tank or a tankless one. Tankless water heaters are rapidly growing in popularity, largely because of their energy efficiency. Tankless water heaters heat water rapidly by running it through a set of heating elements once you turn on the tap, providing you with hot water quickly. However, tankless water heaters may have trouble keeping up with the demands of a large household where multiple people may be trying to use the hot water at the same time.Traditional tank water heaters require energy to keep the water in reserve hot the entire time, whether you’re using it or not. They also take up more space than a tankless model. However, if they are big enough, they can handle a large and diverse hot water demand at once. If you have a large household, this may be something you should take into account.
Water Heater Repair and Replacement Services
Our team of qualified plumbers will help you choose the correct fuel source for your new water heater. We can also help you compare the benefits of tank water heaters and tankless systems. Our team of licensed technicians provides reputable water heater repair, installation, and replacement services for homeowners in Wisconsin and Minnesota.
Our staff offers dependable plumbing services for residents in areas such as Chippewa Falls, Prescott, Lake Hallie, Eau Claire, Mondovi, and Menomonie. Our team has the skills required to help you choose the correct size water heater to meet your needs. To learn more about getting a new water heater, give our staff a call at (715) 802-2170 or schedule an appointment online to receive assistance.
Water Heater FAQs
Depending on the location and the kind of water heater, the cost to flush a water heater can vary considerably. Typically, a flush for the majority of standard water heaters can be completed quickly and efficiently. However, it’s possible that during the flush the plumber finds a bigger problem that needs to be fixed. However, it would be entirely up to you whether or not to address those problems, so you can consider repair costs, age of the water heater and determine if it makes more sense to repair or replace.
There are numerous cost considerations when installing a water heater. The kind of hot water system you want to install and size of the unit will have a significant impact on the cost. Tankless water heaters tend to cost a bit more, but are much more efficient. A water heater installation takes between two and four hours.
If you can’t decide using the 50% rule is one way to achieve your final choice. According to the 50% rule, you should replace an item instead of repairing it if the cost of replacement is greater than 50% of the cost of repair. However, you should keep in mind the frequency of repairs and the age of your water heater even if your current repair does not equal 50% of a new water heater.
The hardness of water, caused by mineral deposits like calcium and magnesium, can affect water heaters by causing scale buildup on heating elements or inside the tank. This buildup reduces efficiency, increases energy consumption, and shortens the lifespan of the heater. Regular maintenance, such as flushing the tank or using a water softener, can mitigate these effects and prolong the heater’s lifespan.
“Mark was very pleasant to work with! He was on time and took care of my plumbing needs efficiently and effectively. I would definitely use him again for any plumbing issues I may have. I have been using Hurlburt for all of my heating, plumbing, and electrical needs and have always been satisfied!”
Alison A.
“Great service! Professionals starting from the first person I spoke to on the phone and finalizing with the person who finished the installation and cleaned up after. Staff explained everything well. Highly recommended!!!”
Jessica F.
"Outstanding service as always! Hurlburt goes above and beyond for their customers. We got scheduled right away, and Shawn did a great job. I will continue to use these guys for everything!!!"
Nicole T.
"Our technician Mike was just awesome. Took the time to show me what he was doing and explained why he was doing it. Gave me an honest evaluation of my situation. You can’t go wrong with Hurlburt and the work ethics of the employees."
Jean C.
Trevor came to service our AC unit. Very happy with his work. Trevor was friendly and knowledgeable, and got our issue fixed quickly. Hurlburt Heating and Plumbing is a great company to work with."
Debbie L.
"Hurlburt has helped us out with both plumbing and HVAC services in the past and have always done a great job. All their technicians, especially Mark, have been kind, professional, and quick with service!"
Sara N.
©2026 Hurlburt. All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy | Terms and Conditions | Cookie Preferences
Web Design and Internet Marketing by RYNO Strategic Solutions
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Google Terms of Service apply.
